What's in the report?
- Authentication from real delivery. SPF is checked against the IP that actually connected, DKIM against the bytes that actually arrived, and DMARC alignment against your From address. A domain check can only guess at these.
- Your sending server. Reverse DNS (and whether it confirms back), the HELO name, TLS, and every blacklist your IP might be on.
- Headers. Message-ID, Date, List-Unsubscribe and the one-click unsubscribe header that Gmail and Yahoo want from bulk senders, plus the delay at every relay hop.
- Content. Plain-text and HTML balance, image-heavy layouts, link shorteners, links whose text shows a different domain than they open, blacklisted link domains, risky attachments, and Gmail's 102 KB clipping limit.
- SpamAssassin. The full score with every rule that fired and what it means, with Razor and Pyzor included. Learning is switched off, so your email doesn't train anything.
How to get a useful result
Send from exactly the setup your recipients see. If your newsletter goes through Mailchimp, send the test from Mailchimp and not from your Gmail, because the two take completely different paths and only one of them is the problem. Use a real subject and real content too; a blank "test" email scores differently from the one you're actually worried about.
The report also runs a full check on your From domain, so you see the DNS side and the message side together.