What is DKIM, in plain words?
DKIM is a signature your mail provider adds to every email, made with a private key that only it holds. The matching public key sits in your DNS under a name like google._domainkey.yourdomain.com, and the receiving server uses it to confirm the email really came through your provider and wasn't changed on the way. Google and Yahoo have required it from bulk senders since February 2024.
What I check
- Whether a key exists. I try a few dozen common selectors at once: google for Google Workspace, selector1 and selector2 for Microsoft 365, s1, k1, mandrill and others for sending tools.
- Key length. 2048-bit RSA is the standard now. 1024-bit keys still work, though it's worth rotating them, and anything shorter gets rejected.
- Microsoft 365 with DKIM switched off. Microsoft always uses selector1 and selector2, so if your mail is on Microsoft and neither exists, DKIM was never enabled. Your email is then signed as your .onmicrosoft.com domain, which does nothing for your own reputation.
- Revoked and test-mode keys. An empty p= means the key was revoked, and t=y tells receivers to treat the signature as a test.
A domain check can't see everything
DNS doesn't let anyone list the selectors on a domain, so if your provider uses an unusual one, a domain check may say there's no key when there is. The definitive answer is a test email. It reads the selector from the actual signature and verifies it, alignment with your From address included.